The hardest item to find on this list is probably the Toy Eyeballs but you can find them at the DollarTree, Amazon or where Halloween items are sold. You will also want the taller shot glasses. The short ones will not work for this drink. Take your shot glass and fill it about half of the way with the peanut butter whiskey. Pour in the grape juice leaving a little space at the top for the eyeball to float.Add in your straw and eyeball. Enjoy!